The Receipts Do Not Rebrand: Musk, Technocapital, and the
Legal Infrastructure of Accountability
Nov 20, 2026
The claim, 18 November 2026
Elon Musk told Andrew Ross Sorkin at the
New York Times DealBook Summit on 18 November 2026: “I’m not MAGA.” He said it
by video link from China, where he was travelling with Donald Trump’s
delegation to the APEC meetings. He added that he was “not sure what MAGA
means”, that he did not hold to “blind adherence” to Republican policy, and
that he is “ideologically quite moderate”. On the money he had spent on the
midterms he said he felt “pretty foolish”. Two weeks earlier, on 3 November
2026, Democrats had taken both chambers of Congress, and in Texas, where Musk
has moved his companies and spent the largest share of his money, both Ken
Paxton and Greg Abbott lost.
The man making this claim wore a black Make
America Great Again cap at a Trump rally in Butler, Pennsylvania on 5 October
2024 and told the crowd he was “dark MAGA”. At Madison Square Garden later that
month he said he was “dark, gothic MAGA”. He gave $277 million to elect Trump
in 2024 and $445.6 million in the 2026 cycle, which makes him the largest
individual political donor in modern American history. He ran the Department of
Government Efficiency. He was photographed in the Oval Office in an oversized MAGA
hat.

Musk circulates video of his own
appearance at Butler, Pennsylvania on 5 October 2024. The caption on screen
reads “I’m dark MAGA.” Posted 6 October 2024, 3.9 million views.
[image: Musk post reading Dark MAGA
Assemble with election night broadcast footage]
“Dark MAGA Assemble!”, posted 6 November
2024 as the result came in. 92.9 million views, 103,000 reposts.
What follows is the record in his own
words, dated, sourced and quotable, then an account of what the rebrand is for,
then the regulatory question that matters more than the man: how democracies
write law that can hold technocapital to account when it invests in their
elections.
A note on method. Every statement below is
one Musk made in public, on his own platform, in an interview, in a signed
op-ed, or from a stage. None of it is inference about his inner beliefs. The
argument does not need his beliefs. It needs his conduct, which is on the
record, and the structural position from which he conducted it, which is a
matter of corporate filings, contracts and campaign disclosures.
The purchase: buying the distribution layer
Everything that follows rests on a
transaction completed on 27 October 2022. Musk paid US$44 billion for Twitter,
took it private and renamed it X. He had spent the preceding months arguing
that the company was failing free speech and undermining democracy by banning
certain accounts. A week after the deal closed, on 4 November 2022, half of a
staff of 7,500 were made redundant, and the cuts fell heavily on the content
moderation and trust and safety teams. In December 2022 the Trust and Safety
Council, a body of around a hundred civil society and human rights
organisations convened in 2016 to advise on hate speech, child exploitation and
self-harm, was dissolved days before it was due to meet.
The gates were then opened. On 19 November
2022 Musk restored Donald Trump’s account on the strength of a poll of his own
followers. Five days later he announced an amnesty for suspended accounts that
had not broken the law, again after a poll, and thousands of accounts banned
for violent threats, harassment and disinformation came back. Nick Fuentes, the
white nationalist described earlier in this paper, was restored in May 2024.
Verification, which had existed to prevent impersonation, was replaced by a paid
subscription that also buys algorithmic priority, so that reach became a
product sold to whoever would pay for it.
The third step is the one that gets least
attention and matters most for regulation. When the Center for Countering
Digital Hate published research showing that hate content on the platform was
going unactioned, X Corp sued the organisation in July 2023. On 25 March 2024
Judge Charles Breyer of the Northern District of California dismissed the suit
under California’s anti-SLAPP law, writing that the case was about punishing
the defendants for their speech, and refusing to allow an amended complaint.
Musk also called Media Matters an evil organisation on the platform in November
2023 as advertisers withdrew. Buying the infrastructure, removing the people
who governed it, readmitting those it had excluded and then litigating against
those who measured the result is a sequence. It produced the conditions for
everything in the two sections that follow.
The record: racial conspiracy, in his own words
On 15 November 2023 an account on X posted
that Jewish communities push “dialectical hatred against whites” while
supporting the arrival of “hordes of minorities”. Musk replied: “You have said
the actual truth.” That is the Great Replacement, the conspiracy theory that
holds that Jews and the left are engineering the demographic displacement of
white populations, and that was cited by the gunman who murdered eleven people
at the Tree of Life synagogue in 2018. The White House called it an “abhorrent
promotion of antisemitic and racist hate” on 17 November 2023. IBM, Apple,
Disney and Lions Gate pulled their advertising. On 29 November 2023, at the
DealBook Summit, the same stage he used this month, Musk said he was sorry for
the post and then told the departing advertisers to go and have sex with
themselves, repeating the instruction for emphasis.

The exchange, dated 15 November 2023 in
contemporaneous reporting and timestamped 16 November in this capture, which
renders in a different time zone. The post Musk endorsed had 2.1 million views.
His four-word reply took 8.7 million.
The apology did not change the pattern.
Musk has told his two hundred million followers that South Africa’s president
has declined to speak against people “openly pushing for genocide of white
people”, a claim a South African court rejected in February 2025 as imagined
rather than real. In May 2025 his chatbot Grok began inserting “white genocide”
and the anti-apartheid song “Kill the Boer” into replies about unrelated
subjects, at one point telling users it had been instructed to treat the claim
as true. xAI blamed an unauthorised modification to the system prompt. The
company has never explained who made it.
On 28 February 2025 Musk told Joe Rogan
that “the fundamental weakness of Western civilization is empathy”, which he
described as an exploit and a bug being used against the West. He said in the
same conversation that he believes in empathy and that people should care about
others, and that the danger lies in what he called suicidal empathy, a term he
took from Gad Saad. The context was immigration. Read with the rest of the
record, the formulation does a specific kind of work: it converts solidarity with
people arriving from the global South into a pathology of the host body.
In May 2024 Musk restored the X account of
Nick Fuentes, a white nationalist who had been removed from mainstream
platforms. By late 2025 that account had passed a million followers, and in
November 2026 Fuentes was publicly calling for a takeover of the Republican
Party by his movement. Reinstatement is not endorsement. It is something more
durable: the provision of distribution infrastructure to a political project
that could not otherwise reach that audience.
The record: the Nazi register
On 20 January 2025, on stage at the Capital
One Arena for Trump’s inauguration rally, Musk twice threw his right arm out
straight above the shoulder. The gesture is contested and should be reported as
contested. The Anti-Defamation League called it awkward enthusiasm rather than
a Nazi salute, and the historian Richard Evans told Euronews it could not be
read as a Nazi gesture. Ruth Ben-Ghiat, who studies fascism at New York
University, called it a Nazi salute and a belligerent one. Claire Aubin, a historian
of Nazism in the United States, called it a sieg heil. Masha Pearl of the Blue
Card, which supports Holocaust survivors, said the same. Musk dismissed the
response as dirty tricks and did not deny the reading. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez
told the ADL it was defending a Heil Hitler salute. Abraham Foxman, the ADL’s
former director, said what came next put the hand gesture in perspective.
What came next is not contested at all.
Five days later, on 25 January 2025, Musk appeared by video before 4,500 people
at an Alternative für Deutschland rally in Halle and told them the party was
“the best hope for Germany”. He told them to take pride in being German, that
multiculturalism dilutes, and then this: “there is too much focus on past
guilt, and we need to move beyond that”. He added that “children should not be
guilty of the sins of their parents, let alone their great-grandparents”. The
rally was two days before International Holocaust Remembrance Day. Donald Tusk,
the Polish prime minister, said the words about forgetting German guilt for
Nazi crimes sounded familiar and ominous. The chairman of Yad Vashem said Musk
had insulted the victims of Nazism and endangered Germany’s democratic future.
This was not an isolated appearance. In
December 2024 Musk posted that “only the AfD can save Germany”, then wrote a
signed op-ed in Welt am Sonntag calling the party the last spark of hope for
the country. On 9 January 2025 he hosted the AfD’s Alice Weidel for a live
conversation on X in which the two discussed Adolf Hitler as a communist. He
was, at the time, the head of a United States government body and the owner of
the platform carrying the broadcast.
In July 2025 the pattern surfaced in the
machinery itself. Days after Musk announced he had improved Grok, the chatbot
spent sixteen hours posting antisemitic content on X, praising Hitler,
attacking users with Jewish surnames and calling itself MechaHitler. xAI
apologised on 12 July 2025 for what it called horrific behaviour and blamed
deprecated code that had made the model susceptible to extremist posts on X.
The apology is itself an admission worth keeping: the company explained that
its model had absorbed the politics of the platform its owner had built.
The record: incitement across borders
On 4 August 2024, while mosques and asylum
hostels in English towns were being attacked by rioters after the Southport
murders, Musk replied to a video of the violence with three words: “Civil war
is inevitable.” Downing Street said there was no justification for the comment.
The justice minister Heidi Alexander called it deeply irresponsible. The
Independent counted it as the sixth time since the previous October that Musk
had claimed civil war was coming to Europe. In the same week he shared a
fabricated news item posted by the co-leader of Britain First, then deleted it,
and he answered the prime minister’s statement about attacks on mosques by
asking what about everyone else. He had already begun calling Keir Starmer
“two-tier Keir”, the slogan the English far right uses to claim that white
people are policed more harshly than Muslims.

4 August 2024, 3:07 pm. The chain under
the reply is the circuit described later in this paper: footage posted by Tommy
Robinson, carried by Libs of TikTok, framed by another account as the effect of
mass migration, and then answered by the owner of the platform. Musk’s three
words took 10 million views.
In January 2025 he turned on a single
minister. Jess Phillips, the safeguarding minister, had declined to order a
Home Office inquiry into child sexual exploitation in Oldham. Musk called her a
“rape genocide apologist” and said she deserved to be in prison. Starmer said
the poison of the far right had led to serious threats against her. A man was
later charged with sending malicious communications to Phillips. This is what
platform ownership does to the ordinary arithmetic of political speech: one
man’s opinion of one minister arrives in front of a hundred million people,
with an algorithm underneath it, and some fraction of that audience acts.
On 13 September 2025 Musk addressed Tommy
Robinson’s Unite the Kingdom rally in London by video, to a crowd police put
well above one hundred thousand. He called for the dissolution of Parliament
and a change of government, described the left as the party of murder, and
said: “Whether you choose violence or not, violence is coming to you. You
either fight back or you die.” Dozens of police officers were injured that day.
Research cited by the Independent counted thirty-four posts or appearances by
Musk about Robinson in a little over a year. Brian Tamaki of Destiny Church
travelled from Aotearoa to take part in the march, which is a useful reminder
that this is one circuit and not three.
Six weeks after that rally the same
argument arrived without the crowd. On 29 October 2025, following the fatal
stabbing of Wayne Broadhurst in Uxbridge, Musk posted a reading of Tolkien in
which the English are the gentlefolk of the shires who survive only because
harder men protect them. He then named the hard man, writing that it was time
for the English to “ally with the hard men, like Tommy Robinson”, and to fight
for their survival or perish. A literary frame is doing specific work there. It
casts a convicted fraudster as the warrior a nation owes its existence to, it
casts migrants as the horror beyond the border, and it tells an audience of
millions that the alternative to armed defence is extinction.

29 October 2025. The quoted post beneath
it is Tommy Robinson’s.
The pattern across those twenty months is
consistent and it has a shape. Musk endorses a nativist party or figure in a
country he does not live in, amplifies them on a platform he owns, attacks the
elected government of that country by name, forecasts or licenses violence, and
then returns to the position that he is a free speech absolutist with no
politics of his own. It has been applied to Germany, Britain, Brazil, Ireland
and the European Union. It is now being applied, in reverse, to his own record.
The 2024 operation: the platform, the money and Turning
Point
Musk founded America PAC in 2024 and was
its sole donor through September, putting in about US$75 million, which rose
past US$118 million during October and made up ninety-one percent of its
declared contributions by December. The committee existed to run canvassing. A
Federal Election Commission ruling in April 2024 allowed super PACs to
coordinate canvassing directly with a campaign, and by September the Guardian
was reporting that Trump’s ground operation in the battleground states had been
largely outsourced to Musk’s committee, which was advertising US$30 an hour for
door knockers and planning three passes at the homes of likely Trump voters in
every battleground state.
The other half of that outsourced operation
belonged to Charlie Kirk. Turning Point Action, the campaign arm of Turning
Point USA, built a ballot chasing programme aimed at low propensity Republican
voters and ran it statewide in Arizona and Wisconsin with hundreds of paid
ballot chasers, and in parts of Michigan and Nevada. In Wisconsin, CBS News
reported, America PAC and Turning Point Action combined forces, with Musk
taking the lead on data and ground operations using Turning Point staff. A
major American party had handed the machinery of voter contact to a
billionaire’s committee and to a movement organisation run by a media
personality, and the billionaire also owned the platform on which the campaign
was being argued.
The inducements followed. In October 2024
Musk announced a daily US$1 million payment to a registered voter in a swing
state who signed his petition, an offer the Department of Justice warned might
be unlawful, and which the Pennsylvania courts allowed to run. Five months
later he repeated the method in a Wisconsin judicial election. The through line
from 2024 to 2026 is a single operating model: own the channel, finance the
contact operation, pay for the signature, and treat each of those as a separate
activity so that no existing law quite covers the combination.
Musk and Kirk were not simply two donors
pointing the same way. Their operations were interlocked in the field, and
their content operations fed each other, which is what made the Springfield
rumour travel the way it did.
Springfield: the rumour that carried the theory into a
presidential campaign
The claim began in a private Facebook group
called Springfield Ohio Crime & Information in the first days of September
2024, in a post relaying that a neighbour’s daughter’s friend had lost a cat to
Haitian arrivals. NewsGuard traced the narrative’s spread to a viral X post on
5 September. On 8 September Charlie Kirk posted the screenshot to his audience
with the assertion that residents of Springfield were reporting that Haitians
were eating pets. On 9 September a Springfield city spokesperson told PolitiFact
there were no credible reports of pets being harmed by anyone in the immigrant
community, and PolitiFact rated the claim false, noting that it had been shared
by Kirk, by Musk, by the House Judiciary Committee and by the vice presidential
nominee JD Vance. On 10 September Donald Trump said it from the debate stage to
tens of millions of viewers.
Musk carried it hardest. Slate counted him
posting or sharing material about Springfield and immigrants eating pets at
least eight times, several of the posts built around AI generated memes, to an
audience of 197 million. On 18 September, eight days after the city had denied
it and nine days after the fact check, CNN reported that Musk reshared a video
falsely claiming the Springfield city manager had admitted there were reports
of Haitians eating pets, captioning it with a jab at ABC News. On the same day
he amplified a fabricated bomb threat story about a Trump rally, which was
community noted as false while his post stayed up.
One frame holds the whole mechanism.
Charlie Kirk’s post of 9 September 2024 reproduces the original Facebook
warning from the private Springfield group, sets it beside a headline about
twenty thousand Haitian migrants, and states the theory outright by calling the
arrivals a gift of the “mass immigration replacement plan”. Musk answered it at
2:26 that afternoon with a single line: “Apparently, people’s pet cats are
being eaten.” Kirk’s post took 4.1 million views and 11,000 reposts. Musk’s
reply took 1.7 million. This was the same day the city told PolitiFact there
were no credible reports, and the same day the fact check was published.

9 September 2024. The Facebook
screenshot inside Kirk’s post is the origin document: a second-hand account of
a neighbour’s daughter’s friend’s cat.
The memes carried further than any of the
claims. On the morning of 10 September 2024, hours before the presidential
debate, Musk posted an AI-generated picture of a duckling and a kitten over two
words and a weeping emoji: “Save them!” It registered 96.1 million views,
650,000 likes and 68,000 reposts. Five days later he did it again, an
AI-generated kitten and puppy cradled in a human hand, this time attached to a
New York Post story from 14 September about animal remains found in New York’s
Jamaica Bay, a story with no connection to Springfield, to Ohio or to Haitian
people. That post took 46.5 million views.

10 September 2024, 7:06 am, the morning
of the debate. The image is AI-generated. 96.1 million views, 650,000 likes,
68,000 reposts.
[image: Musk post reading Save them with an
AI-generated kitten and puppy over a New York Post story]
15 September 2024. The quoted New York
Post report, dated 14 September, concerns animal remains found in New York’s
Jamaica Bay and has nothing to do with Springfield or with Haitian residents.
46.5 million views.
Those two posts together registered 142.6
million impressions. Impressions are not people and one person can account for
many, so the figure is not a count of an audience. It is a measure of how far a
thing was pushed, and it is larger than the total vote cast for either
candidate in the election it was pushed into. The form matters as much as the
scale. A picture of a kitten makes no claim, states no fact and names no
person, which is exactly why the city’s denial and PolitiFact’s rating could
not touch it. The accusation is carried entirely by the context the poster has
already built, and the only thing left to argue with is a feeling. This is the
register in which the Great Replacement now travels, and no fact-checking
regime yet designed has any purchase on it.
The city of about sixty thousand people,
with a Haitian population estimated at the time at twelve to fifteen thousand,
then received bomb threats against multiple facilities. City hall was evacuated
and closed, schools were shut, and Haitian families stayed home. The Governor
of Ohio and city officials said repeatedly that the claims were untrue.
Reporting published this month records bomb threats referencing Haitians
closing Springfield’s schools again in February 2026, seventeen months after
the original claim had been publicly disproven, which is a single-source
account and is flagged here as such.
What this episode demonstrates belongs at
the centre of any regulatory argument. The rumour was debunked by the relevant
city authority before it reached its largest audience, and the debunking
changed nothing, because the people with distribution kept pushing. It worked
as campaign material precisely because it rendered the Great Replacement thesis
as an image a person could hold: the newcomer who consumes what is yours.
Musk’s November 2023 affirmation of that theory and his September 2024 memes
about Springfield are the same argument at two levels of abstraction. One is a
statement of doctrine and the other is a joke about a cat, and the second
travels further.
The amplification network
Libs of TikTok shows how the circuit runs.
The account is operated by Chaya Raichik, a former Brooklyn real estate agent,
and it works by selecting a hospital, a school, a teacher or a librarian and
placing them in front of a very large audience as a danger to children. In
August 2022, after the account and others falsely claimed that Boston
Children’s Hospital was performing hysterectomies on children, the hospital
reported a wave of hostile calls, harassing emails and threats of violence
against its clinicians, and police responded to an anonymous bomb threat.
Children’s National Hospital in Washington received the same treatment after a
similar post. Wikipedia’s account of the record counts at least sixty bomb
threats linked to the account’s posts, and the Southern Poverty Law Center
records that some hospitals suspended care or stripped information from their
websites in response.
Musk’s part in this is active rather than
passive. Under his ownership the account was restored and grew, and he
functions as its escalation route: Raichik tags him in complaints to her
millions of followers and he answers and amplifies to his own audience, which
is roughly sixty times larger. He attacked the Anti-Defamation League publicly
for pushing X to shut down what he called accounts like Chaya’s, saying this
had nothing to do with antisemitism, and agreed to release platform data he
said would expose the campaign against her. The owner of the infrastructure
took the side of the account against the organisation documenting its effects,
and did so in public.
That is the pattern the whole record
repeats. The November 2022 amnesty returned accounts that had been removed for
threats and harassment, including accounts with neo-Nazi politics. Nick Fuentes
was restored in May 2024. Tommy Robinson was readmitted in November 2023 and
subsequently addressed or was addressed by Musk thirty-four times in little
over a year. Alice Weidel was given a live platform with the owner in January
2025. What each of these people gained was not an argument from Musk. It was
reach, supplied free, by the person who controls the setting that determines
reach.
This is the gap that current law does not
reach. Every regulatory regime in the democratic world is built to police what
is said and who paid for an advertisement. None of them governs the decision to
hand an audience of two hundred million to a selected set of political actors
while withholding it from others, which is a decision made continuously, by one
owner, without disclosure, and at no cost that any statute currently prices.
Foreign interference, in both directions
On 25 October 2024, eleven days before the
presidential election, the Wall Street Journal reported that Musk had been in
regular contact with Vladimir Putin since late 2022, citing current and former
officials in the United States, Europe and Russia, and said the conversations
covered business, geopolitics and personal matters. The same reporting said
Putin had asked Musk not to activate Starlink over Taiwan as a favour to Xi
Jinping. The Kremlin denied it, with Dmitry Peskov saying there had been one phone
call before 2022 about future technology. Bill Nelson, then the NASA
administrator, called for an investigation, which matters because the man in
question is one of the largest contractors to the United States government.
The context is a record of private
decisions with the weight of state decisions. In September 2022 Starlink
service was withheld near occupied Crimea, disrupting a Ukrainian attack, and
Musk said he had declined an urgent request to switch it on. In October 2022 he
published a peace plan for a war he was supplying communications to, proposing
that Ukraine cede territory and stay out of NATO. The reported subpoena plan in
Washington this month covers precisely this ground. No statute currently
answers the question it raises, which is what obligations attach to a private
person who owns a communications system that a state at war depends on.
The second direction is the one that
reaches Aotearoa. Musk is a private citizen of another country in every
jurisdiction he has intervened in, and he has intervened in Germany, the United
Kingdom, Ireland, Brazil and the institutions of the European Union, endorsing
parties, demanding the dissolution of a parliament, attacking named ministers
and calling for governments to fall. New Zealand law meets a foreign donor with
a strict rule: an overseas person may give $50, and a party must take all
reasonable steps to confirm that any larger donation is not from overseas. New
Zealand law meets a foreign platform owner who gives a local far right campaign
fifty million impressions with no rule at all.
That asymmetry is the sharpest single
argument in this paper. Every democracy has decided that foreign money in
elections is a threat requiring statutory control. The same democracies have
left foreign-owned distribution, which is the more effective instrument,
entirely unregulated as an electoral matter. The donation rule is enforced
against a $100 cheque from an expatriate while the owner of the channel
operates without limit, without disclosure and without any requirement even to
report what he has done. Closing that gap does not require new principles. It
requires applying the principle already accepted about money to the asset that
has replaced it.
The money, 2024 to 2026
Musk has put at least US$748 million of
disclosed money into United States elections across two cycles, which makes him
the largest individual donor in modern American history and, by OpenSecrets’
count of the 2026 cycle alone, nearly three times the size of the next biggest.
|
Cycle
or race |
Where
it went |
Amount
(US$) |
Result |
|
2026 midterms |
$445.6m in FEC filings to 14 Oct 2026,
including $168m to the Senate Leadership Fund, of which $158m reached the
Texas PAC backing Ken Paxton, and $10m to a super PAC for Nate Morris in
Kentucky |
445.6m |
Democrats took both chambers; Paxton and
Abbott lost Texas |
|
Wisconsin Supreme Court, Apr 2025 |
About $22m through America PAC for Brad
Schimel, plus $100 payments to petition signers and three cheques of $1m each |
at least 25m |
Susan Crawford won by 10 points;
litigation continues |
|
2024 presidential |
$239m to his own America PAC, $10m to the
Senate Leadership Fund, $3m to the MAHA Alliance, plus a $1m-a-day giveaway
to petition signers that the Department of Justice warned might be unlawful |
277m |
Trump elected; Musk appointed to lead
DOGE |
Set that against the scale of the capital
behind it. On 6 November 2025 Tesla shareholders approved a pay package worth
up to US$1 trillion over a decade, and Musk’s net worth at the time of that
vote was reported at US$437 billion. The $445.6 million he now calls foolish is
about one tenth of one percent of his personal wealth. For any New Zealand
party the same sum would be more than two hundred times the entire regulated
campaign spending limit of $1,503,000 for the 2026 general election. A rounding
error in one man’s portfolio is several national election cycles in most
democracies, and that asymmetry is the whole regulatory problem in a single
line.
What the rebrand is for
The disavowal is timed to a change in who
holds subpoena power. Senate Democrats were reported on 18 November 2026, the
same week as the DealBook appearance, to be planning to subpoena Musk over his
time running DOGE, over SpaceX’s government contracts, over the use of Starlink
and Starshield in Ukraine, and over his dealings with Vladimir Putin. From
January 2027 the committees that write those subpoenas have majorities. A
Senate minority staff report of April 2025 had already found Musk and his
companies facing at least sixty-five actual or potential enforcement actions
across eleven federal agencies, with at least US$2.37 billion in potential
liability, at the moment he was given authority over the agencies conducting
them. Moderation is the posture a defendant adopts before a hearing.
The second audience is commercial. Tesla
sales fell across Europe through 2025, including a fifty percent collapse in
Germany in the month before the pay vote, and the brand damage tracked his
political interventions rather than the product. He delivered the DealBook
remarks from China, where he was travelling with the American president’s
delegation, in a market that decides the fate of his car company. Saying that
one has no fixed politics is cheaper than dismantling the apparatus that cost
the sales.
The third move is the one worth naming
precisely, because it is a communicative inversion. The largest political donor
in American history, the man who said on stage that he was dark gothic MAGA,
now says he is “not sure what MAGA means”. Ignorance is offered as an alibi by
the person who paid for the thing he claims not to recognise. Half a billion
dollars is recoded as prudent portfolio management, a hedge so that one chamber
or the presidency stays Republican in 2029. The explicitly ideological becomes
merely technical. That reframing asks the public to accept that money carries
no meaning, which is precisely the claim that makes money ungovernable.
Nothing is being given back and nothing is
being switched off. The platform still ranks what it ranks. Nick Fuentes still
has his account and his million followers. Grok still trains on the output of
that platform. The Great Replacement is now standard vocabulary in four
Anglophone parliaments. Steve Bannon put the principle plainly when the
alliance was forming: when you write cheques of that size, you have a seat at
the table. Walking away from the label does not vacate the seat. The
institutions that were reshaped stay reshaped, which is why accountability has
to attach to the structure and not to the stated affiliation of the man who
owns it.
Technocapital as a political form
Four kinds of power sat in one pair of
hands between January 2025 and May 2025, and they had never before been held
together. Musk owned the communicative infrastructure through which a large
share of the world’s political argument passes. He owned physical
infrastructure that states depend on and cannot quickly replace, including
satellite communications used in an active war. He deployed electoral money
without limit. And he held administrative office inside the government that
regulates all three. Each of those powers is individually familiar. Hearst
owned newspapers. Krupp owned factories. The combination is what is new, and
the combination is what the law was never written for.
The classical definition of fascism turns
on the fusion of corporate and state power behind a project of racial and
national renewal. The fusion in this case ran in an unfamiliar direction.
Capital absorbed the administrative functions of the state rather than the
state absorbing capital. A private citizen with ten billion dollars in Defence
Department contracts was given authority to restructure the agencies auditing
him, and Public Citizen found conflicts of interest at twenty-three of the
agencies DOGE reached. Mark Coeckelbergh’s account of technofascism in AI &
Society in 2026 locates the danger in exactly this combination of platform
dominance, mythic self-presentation and authoritarian politics, and reaches the
same conclusion this paper reaches about remedy: regulation plus democratic
renewal plus structural change, rather than better behaviour by owners.
The culture-centered question is what
happens to voice under these conditions. Control of the infrastructure of
communication is control over which registers of speech reach a hearing, and
that control operates through ranking rather than prohibition. A nine-month Sky
News audit published in November 2025 found that newly created accounts in the
United Kingdom, whatever their stated politics, were served right-wing and
extreme content. An audit presented at the ACM conference on Fairness,
Accountability and Transparency in June 2025 found exposure skewed toward a
small number of high-reach right-leaning accounts during the 2024 election. A
field experiment reported in 2026 found that the algorithmic feed raised the
share of right-leaning content by 2.9 percentage points against a chronological
feed, and that the following patterns it created survived a return to the
chronological feed. Nobody was silenced in any of these studies. The
architecture simply decided whose speech would travel, and the decision was made
by a private owner with a declared politics and no duty to anyone.
The people who carry the cost of that
decision are the people who always carry it. The Great Replacement vocabulary
that Musk affirmed in November 2023 names Jews as conspirators and migrants of
colour as the instrument. The civil war vocabulary he used in August 2024 was
deployed while mosques were being attacked. The white genocide vocabulary he
and his chatbot pushed in 2025 rewrites a post-apartheid state as a site of
anti-white persecution. In Aotearoa the same grammar arrives as a claim that
Indigenous rights are racial privilege. The material consequences land on
Muslim communities, on migrants, on Māori, on everyone whose claim to the
public sphere was already conditional. That is the register in which
technocapital does its political work, and it is the reason the regulatory
question cannot be left to a theory of markets.
Regulating the investment of technocapital in elections
The American route is closed and other
democracies should stop treating it as the model. Buckley v. Valeo in 1976 and
Citizens United in 2010 converted political spending into protected speech, and
the courts have since extended that protection to money with foreign ownership
behind it. Minnesota legislated in 2023 to bar corporations with as little as
one percent foreign ownership from spending in its elections, and a federal
judge permanently enjoined the provision on 7 February 2025 in Minnesota Chamber
of Commerce v. Choi. Maine voters passed a narrower version by ballot
initiative in November 2023 using a five percent threshold, and the First
Circuit affirmed an injunction against it on 11 July 2025. When Wisconsin’s
attorney general asked the state Supreme Court to stop Musk handing million
dollar cheques to voters days before a judicial election, the court declined to
hear the case on 30 March 2025, and he handed out the cheques that evening. A
constitutional order that cannot prevent a billionaire paying voters during an
election campaign is not a source of regulatory design for anyone else.
The instruments that do work are
unglamorous and they already exist in fragments across the Commonwealth and the
European Union. What is missing is the decision to use them together.
•
A hard annual cap on what any
single person or entity may give to parties, candidates and third parties
combined, set low enough that no fortune can outbid a membership base.
•
Beneficial ownership disclosure
for every donation above a modest threshold, so that money routed through
trusts, holding companies and charitable foundations is traced to the person
who actually paid.
•
Registration, spending caps and
donor disclosure for third party campaigners that bind for the full election
year rather than a short regulated period, since the money moves to whatever
window the law leaves open.
•
A statutory prohibition on
payments, lotteries and prizes offered to voters or petition signers during a
campaign, with civil standing for electoral commissions and for ordinary
electors to enforce it.
•
A pay to play bar preventing
entities holding major public contracts, and their controlling owners, from
funding parties or third party campaigns while those contracts run.
•
Treatment of owner-directed
algorithmic amplification as a disclosable in-kind contribution where a
platform owner intervenes personally on behalf of a candidate or cause.
That last instrument is the hardest and the
most necessary. Everything else on the list regulates the movement of money,
and the decisive asset in 2024, 2025 and 2026 was not money. It was
distribution. Musk’s spending in Wisconsin and Texas failed, and his
amplification of the AfD, of Tommy Robinson and of the Great Replacement
succeeded, because distribution shifts what a population believes is normal
while advertising only shifts what it believes about one candidate. No
jurisdiction has yet written a workable test for valuing amplification as a
contribution, and the measurement problem is real: it requires access to
ranking data that platforms do not surrender voluntarily. The European route
points at the answer, which is to make the data accessible first and then price
what it shows.
Regulating the platform
On 5 December 2025 the European Commission
issued the first non-compliance decision under the Digital Services Act and
fined X €120 million for the deceptive design of its blue checkmark, for the
state of its advertising repository, and for failing to give researchers access
to public data. The reaction mapped the terrain precisely. Musk claimed he had
been fined personally, which the Commission denied on 8 December, saying it
does not fine individuals. Marco Rubio called the decision an attack on American
tech platforms and on the American people. JD Vance accused the Commission of
seeking censorship. X and Musk went to the General Court in February 2026 to
have the decision annulled, and the case is live. Any country that regulates
this sector should expect its decisions to be answered by the foreign ministry
of the United States, and should plan for that rather than be surprised by it.
The third of those three findings is the
one that matters most for everything else in this paper. Without access to
ranking and reach data there is no way to measure amplification, no way to
value it as a contribution, and no way to test any claim about algorithmic bias
in court. The evidence cited earlier in this paper exists because journalists
built sockpuppet accounts and academics ran field experiments, which is an
expensive and partial substitute for an audit right. Mandatory, enforceable,
independently administered researcher access is the precondition of every other
instrument, and it should be written into electoral law as well as into
platform law so that electoral commissions hold it too.
The European experience also carries a
warning about instrument design. Regulation (EU) 2024/900 on the transparency
and targeting of political advertising applied from 10 October 2025, and
Google, Meta, TikTok and LinkedIn responded by withdrawing from political
advertising in the Union altogether, with Google deleting its political ads
archive on the way out. Paid political manipulation did not stop. It moved to
organic amplification, influencer payments and the owner’s own account, while
the archive that let researchers watch it disappeared. The design lesson is to
make retention and public deposit of advertising archives a standing obligation
that survives a platform’s exit from a market, and to write transparency duties
so that compliance is cheaper than withdrawal.
Penalties have to be set against the
balance sheet they are meant to deter. A €120 million fine against a company
whose owner was worth US$437 billion in November 2025 is a licensing fee.
Turnover-based penalties with escalating periodic payments, personal liability
for executives who direct non-compliance, and conditions on market access for
repeat breaches are the only sanctions that register at this scale. Two further
duties belong alongside them. Where an owner, executive or employee manually
intervenes in ranking or in a model’s instructions, the intervention should be
logged and disclosable to the regulator, which is the obligation that would
have answered xAI’s claim in May 2025 that an unauthorised modification made
Grok push white genocide claims. And deployed models at this scale should carry
incident reporting duties with statutory deadlines, the way the aviation and
pharmaceutical sectors do, because MechaHitler in July 2025 and the sexualised
Grok images that drew comment from the New Zealand prime minister’s office in
January 2026 were not accidents of nature. They were product releases.
Regulating the interface between capital and the state
Between January and May 2025 the owner of
SpaceX directed a body that was restructuring the agencies regulating SpaceX.
The Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations minority staff counted at
least sixty-five actual or potential enforcement matters against Musk and his
companies at eleven federal agencies, carrying at least US$2.37 billion in
exposure, as of inauguration day. Public Citizen found conflicts of interest at
twenty-three of the agencies DOGE touched, which was more than seven in ten of
them. Senator Blumenthal put SpaceX and Starlink’s federal contracts at roughly
US$19.8 billion. Senator Warren’s office catalogued more than a hundred
instances in which Musk or people acting for him took actions that bore on his
own businesses, including the embedding of Starlink in Federal Aviation
Administration communications while DOGE was pressing the agency on costs.
The legal fix here is old and well
understood, which makes the failure to apply it a political choice rather than
a drafting problem. Divestment or a genuinely blind trust as a condition of
holding office. Recusal that is automatic, logged and published rather than
asserted by a press secretary. Inspectors general with statutory protection
against removal by the people they investigate. Debarment available against
contractors whose controlling owners interfere with their own regulators. A
standing bar on any person holding office that supervises an agency from which
their companies hold material contracts. New Zealand and Australia both have
versions of these rules for ministers and officials, and both have versions
that are weaker than they look once contracting and advisory roles are
involved.
Dependency is the harder problem and the
one small states should treat as urgent. Ukraine discovered in the middle of a
war that battlefield communications ran through a constellation owned by a
private individual who held his own views about the war and his own channel to
Moscow. No defence ministry, no emergency management agency and no
telecommunications regulator should accept a position in which continuity of
service depends on the political mood of an owner. The instruments are
contractual and structural: step-in rights and continuity obligations written
into procurement, escrowed control of critical functions, interoperability
requirements so that a second supplier can be switched in, mandatory
diversification above a dependency threshold, and national interest review of
acquisitions that create such dependencies in the first place.
The same logic runs down to the smallest
decisions. Government agencies in Aotearoa still publish official
communications on X, a platform fined by the European Commission for breaching
transparency obligations and audited by Sky News as systematically amplifying
extreme content. Public communication is procurement. It should carry
conditions, and the condition should be that a platform carrying official
notices meets a published standard of transparency, researcher access and
complaint handling, with an exit plan that is written before it is needed
rather than during the crisis that makes it necessary.
Aotearoa New Zealand: the gaps that are already being used
New Zealand has one strong rule and a set
of open doors. Since December 2019 an overseas person may give no more than $50
to a party or candidate, a limit passed under urgency to keep foreign money
out. There is no cap at all on what a New Zealand person or company may give.
Parties disclose donations over $6,000 in their annual returns and over $20,000
within twenty working days during an election year. During the regulated
period, which ran from 7 August to 6 November for the 2026 election, a party could
spend $1,503,000 on election advertising plus $36,000 for each electorate
candidate. Outside that period there are no advertising spending limits
whatsoever, and large foreign money can still be routed through New Zealand
companies, trusts and foundations.
Those doors were used in 2026. Writing in
Newsroom on 9 November, Lianne Dalziel described seven groups centred on the
Taxpayers’ Union network, among them Hobson’s Pledge Trust, Family First and
Voices for Freedom, registering as third party promoters, with organisations
including the Free Speech Union able to spend upwards of $400,000 each on
attack advertising. Harry Mowbray’s Split Your Vote campaign and Don Brash’s
full page advertisements urged centre right voters to engineer the composition
of Parliament, and the network behind that campaign is documented in Nicky
Hager’s Dirty Work. Questions about who paid for Reality Check Radio’s
distribution of around a million flyers have not been answered. None of this
required a single dollar from Elon Musk.
What Musk supplies to Aotearoa is
vocabulary, distribution and permission. The grammar that turns Indigenous
rights into racial privilege, that turns migrants into an invasion and that
turns disagreement into civil war is written in English, travels on a platform
he owns and is ranked by an algorithm his company tunes. Brian Tamaki stood at
Tommy Robinson’s march in London in September 2025 while Musk told that crowd
to fight back or die. The pipeline is not metaphorical. It has owners, budgets
and a distribution layer, and it reaches here as reliably as it reaches Halle
or Oldham.
The legislative work is specific and
available now. Cap donations from any single source. Extend spending limits
beyond the regulated period so that money cannot simply arrive in June. Require
third party promoters to register earlier, to disclose their own donors, and to
trace money through trusts and foundations to the person who provided it. Build
the lobbying register that successive governments have declined to build. Write
synthetic media rules for elections, since the country was described as lagging
on deepfakes in January 2026 while Grok was being used to generate sexualised
images of real people. And keep one thing in view while doing all of it:
regulating money does not regulate meaning. Caps would have changed the budget
of the 2026 attack campaign and would not have changed the story it told. The
counter to that story is built in communities, in the register of voice rather
than the register of compliance, and no statute will do that work on anyone’s
behalf.
What accountability requires
Brazil settled the question of whether this
is possible. On 30 August 2024 Justice Alexandre de Moraes suspended X across
the country for refusing court orders. Musk called him a dictator and said he
would not comply. Six weeks later X had blocked the accounts named by the
court, appointed a legal representative in Brazil and paid the outstanding
fines, and on 8 October 2024 the suspension was lifted. Twenty-one million
users were the argument. Compliance followed market access rather than
persuasion, and it took a state willing to accept several weeks of abuse from
the richest man alive.
No country the size of New Zealand will run
that play on its own, and the European Commission’s experience in December 2025
shows that even a market of four hundred million draws a response from the
American State Department. The answer is a standing coordination among middle
powers that each lack the leverage individually: shared evidentiary standards,
mutual recognition of each other’s findings so that one regulator’s audit is
admissible in another’s proceedings, a joint technical facility capable of auditing
ranking systems, common penalty floors calculated on global turnover, and
synchronised compliance deadlines so that a firm cannot play jurisdictions
against each other. Aotearoa, Australia, Canada, Brazil, South Africa, the
European Union and the United Kingdom together hold a market no platform can
write off.
Liability has to reach the people who make
the decisions. Corporate fines are absorbed as operating costs. The design that
bites includes personal liability for owners and executives who direct
non-compliance, removal of the defence that an unauthorised change or an
autonomous model caused the harm, a statutory duty of care enforceable by
individuals and not only by regulators, funded standing for the communities who
carry the consequences of amplified hate, and evidence preservation obligations
with protection for the employees who disclose breaches. The Great Replacement
post of 15 November 2023 and the sixteen hours of MechaHitler in July 2025 each
produced apologies and no liability at all. That is the gap.
One further protection belongs in the
architecture. The people who document this work get named from the stage. Jess
Phillips was called a rape genocide apologist by a man with two hundred million
followers, and a prosecution followed for the messages she then received. Media
Matters was called an evil organisation on the same platform. Academics,
journalists and civil society researchers in every jurisdiction mentioned in
this paper have been through smaller versions of the same treatment. Legal
infrastructure that regulates technocapital without protecting the people who
produce the evidence against it will not survive its first serious test.
Protection of that work is part of the regulatory design, not a welfare measure
attached to it.
The record set out in the first half of
this paper does not expire because its author has decided to describe himself
differently in November 2026. The task for anyone writing law in this field is
to make that true in statute: to attach exposure to conduct and to structural
position, so that the question a court asks is what a person did, what they
owned while doing it and who carried the cost, rather than what they say they
were.
Sources
All pages below were opened and checked on
20 November 2026. Two matters are flagged rather than asserted. The plan to
subpoena Musk is second-hand reporting of a report in The Hill dated 18
November 2026 and has not been confirmed by a committee. Crowd estimates for
the London rally of 13 September 2025 vary between about 110,000 and 150,000
depending on the source, and the Metropolitan Police figure sits at the lower
end. The February 2026 bomb threats against Springfield schools rest on one
source and are marked as such in the text.
The DealBook claim, November 2026
•
NBC News, Elon
Musk says he is ‘not MAGA’ after spending millions on Trump and his allies,
18 November 2026
•
The Hill, Musk
says he’s ‘not MAGA’, 19 November 2026
•
TechCrunch, Elon Musk
says: ‘I’m not MAGA’, 18 November 2026
•
Fortune, From
‘dark MAGA’ to ‘not MAGA’ after spending $445 million, 19 November 2026
•
ABC News, Musk
regrets nearly $500 million midterm spending, 19 November 2026
Great Replacement and antisemitism
•
Forward, ‘You
have said the actual truth’, 16 November 2023
•
Jewish Telegraphic Agency, IBM
pulls its ads from X, 17 November 2023
•
Variety, Musk
to advertisers who pulled spending, 29 November 2023
South Africa and Grok
•
Axios, Grok
makes ‘white genocide’ claims, 14 May 2025
•
NBC News, Grok
brings up South African white genocide claims, 15 May 2025
•
Eyewitness News, xAI
blames unauthorised tweak, 17 May 2025
•
TechCrunch, xAI
and Grok apologize for ‘horrific behavior’, 12 July 2025
The salute and the AfD
•
Jewish Telegraphic Agency, Musk’s
straight-armed gesture, 20 January 2025
•
Al Jazeera, ADL
faces backlash for defending Musk’s gesture, 22 January 2025
•
Euronews, Did
Elon Musk give a ‘Nazi’ salute?, 22 January 2025
•
Jewish Telegraphic Agency, ‘There
is too much focus on past guilt’, 25 January 2025
•
Forbes, Musk
addresses the AfD in surprise rally appearance, 25 January 2025
•
NBC News, Yad
Vashem chairman on Musk’s AfD appearance, 27 January 2025
•
Centre on Hate, Bias and
Extremism, Ontario Tech University, Trump
redux: implications for the international far-right
Britain
•
Fortune, British
PM calls out Musk over ‘civil war is inevitable’, 5 August 2024
•
The Independent via AOL, Downing
Street condemns Musk, 5 August 2024
•
PA via Yahoo, Man
charged with malicious communications to Jess Phillips
•
NBC News, London
braces for mass far-right rally, 13 September 2025
•
The Journal, ‘You
either fight back or you die’, 14 September 2025
•
The Independent via AOL, How
Tommy Robinson pulled off his biggest march
•
Rolling Stone Australia, Brian
Tamaki at Unite the Kingdom, September 2025
Empathy
•
WUSF and NPR, How
empathy came to be seen as a weakness, 22 March 2025, transcript of the 28
February 2025 Joe Rogan Experience remarks
The money
•
CBS News, Musk
spends $277 million to back Trump, December 2024
•
Newsweek, Musk
spent at least $25M on the Wisconsin race, April 2025
•
Wisconsin Watch, Are
the cash giveaways legal?, 30 March 2025
•
PBS Wisconsin and AP, Lawsuit
seeks to ban Musk from offering cash payments, 11 June 2025
•
Time, Musk
could get charged with breaking election law, 15 July 2026
•
NPR, Musk
will face scrutiny from Democrats after midterms, 4 November 2026
•
The Hill, Musk
spent big on Republicans. He has little to show for it, 8 November 2026
•
PBS and AP, Tesla
shareholders approve the pay package, 6 November 2025
•
CBS News, Shareholders
approve $1 trillion pay package, 6 November 2025
DOGE and conflicts of interest
•
US Senate Permanent
Subcommittee on Investigations, minority staff, memorandum
on Elon Musk’s conflicts, 28 April 2025
•
Office of Senator Elizabeth
Warren, 130
Days of Elon Musk, June 2025
•
Public Citizen, Duplicitous
Oligarch Grifting Endlessly, 2025
•
Via Satellite, Blumenthal
on DOGE and SpaceX, 10 February 2025
Platform regulation
•
CNBC, X
fined €120 million by the European Commission, 5 December 2025
•
Tech Policy Press, Unpacking
the politics of the EU’s €120M fine, 7 December 2025
•
EUobserver, Tensions
boil over after the fine, 8 December 2025
•
Corporate INTL, Why
is the European Commission fining X?, 2026, for the procedural timeline and
the February 2026 annulment action
•
Meta Newsroom, Ending
political, electoral and social issue advertising in the EU, 25 July 2025
•
EUobserver, Meta
and Google stop political ads, hurting research, 14 October 2025
Algorithmic amplification
•
ACM FAccT 2025, Auditing
political exposure bias on Twitter/X during the 2024 US election
•
The Conversation, A
few weeks of X’s algorithm can make you more right-wing, 2026
•
WinBuzzer summary of the Sky
News nine-month investigation, X
algorithm boosts right-wing politics in the UK, 6 November 2025
United States campaign finance
litigation
•
National Conference of State
Legislatures, Foreign
campaign contributions and expenditures
•
US District Court for the
District of Minnesota, Minnesota
Chamber of Commerce v. Choi, opinion and order, 7 February 2025
•
Free Speech For People, statement
on the First Circuit decision on Maine’s law, 11 July 2025
Brazil
•
NPR, X
to be reinstated in Brazil, 8 October 2024
•
Columbia Global Freedom of
Expression, The
case of the X ban in Brazil
Aotearoa New Zealand
•
Electoral Commission, rules
for party donations and loans
•
RNZ, How
private donors fund political campaigns, 2026
•
Library of Congress, New
Zealand: restrictions on foreign donations passed under urgency, 11
December 2019
•
Lianne Dalziel, Newsroom, Did
right-wing attack ad spending sway the election?, 9 November 2026
•
Bryce Edwards, News
briefing, 9 November 2026, for the list of registered third party promoters
•
Newsroom, How
to use the Mowbray-Brash campaign as a catalyst to fix MMP, 11 November
2026
•
RNZ, The
X factor: Grok deepfakes and why NZ is still using Elon Musk’s X, January
2026
The purchase and the platform
•
PolitiFact, How
Elon Musk ditched Twitter's safeguards, 23 October 2023
•
CBS News and AP, Musk
announces ‘amnesty’ for suspended Twitter accounts, 24 November 2022
•
Forbes, Musk
is restoring banned Twitter accounts, 25 November 2022
•
PBS NewsHour and AP, Musk’s
Twitter dissolves the Trust and Safety advisory group, December 2022
•
AFP via Malay Mail, Twitter
timeline from Musk’s entry, 21 December 2022, for the 4 November staff cuts
•
Knight First Amendment
Institute, X
Corp. v. Center for Countering Digital Hate, case page
•
CBS News, Judge
tosses out X lawsuit against hate-speech researchers, 25 March 2024
•
NPR, Judge
dismisses Musk’s suit against hate speech researchers, 25 March 2024
The 2024 operation and Turning Point
•
CBS News, Outside
groups bolster Trump’s voter mobilization, October 2024
•
Denver Gazette, Behind
the scenes of Trump’s big ground game gamble, 16 October 2024
•
True North Research, Musk
pours money into the 2025 Wisconsin Supreme Court race, March 2025, for the
FEC coordination ruling and the TPUSA collaboration
•
The American Prospect, Trying
to find Trump’s ground game in Pennsylvania, 24 October 2024
•
America PAC, for
contribution totals and Musk’s share of declared contributions
Springfield
•
PolitiFact, Authorities
rebut claims that Haitian immigrants are eating pets, 9 September 2024
•
ABC News, Timeline
of unsubstantiated claims about Haitian immigrants in Springfield, 13
September 2024
•
Slate, How
Trump, Elon Musk and the GOP spread this lie, September 2024, for the count
of Musk’s posts
•
CNN, Musk
boosts fake Trump rally bomb threat and false claims, 18 September 2024
•
CBC, Springfield receives bomb threats, 12
September 2024
•
The Disinformation Observer, What
folklore already knew, November 2026, the single source for the February
2026 threats
Libs of TikTok and the amplification
network
•
Libs of TikTok, for the
count of at least sixty linked bomb threats
•
Southern Poverty Law Center, extremist
file on Chaya Raichik
•
Washington Post reporting
entered into the Congressional record, Libs
of TikTok blamed for harassment of children’s hospitals
•
The Advocate, Musk
agrees to a Libs of TikTok request for an X data dump on the ADL
•
NBC News, Libs
of TikTok creator named to Oklahoma library board, 2024
Russia, Starlink and foreign
interference
•
CNN, NASA
chief calls for an investigation into the Musk and Putin report, 25 October
2024
•
ABC News, Musk
is in ‘regular contact’ with Vladimir Putin, 25 October 2024
•
Axios, Elon
Musk and Putin have ‘regular contact’, 25 October 2024
•
Euromaidan Press, WSJ
uncovers Musk’s regular communications with the Kremlin, 25 October 2024,
for the September 2022 Crimea decision
•
AFP via Malay Mail, Russia
denies the secret talks, 25 October 2024
Primary documents reproduced in this
paper
Eight captures of posts on X, supplied as
screenshots and reproduced above as evidence of the posts themselves. View and
repost counts are those shown in each capture at the time it was taken.
•
Elon Musk replying “You have
said the actual truth” to a post about Jewish communities and minorities, 15
November 2023 (timestamped 16 November in the capture), 8.7 million views
•
Elon Musk replying “Civil war
is inevitable” to footage circulated by Tommy Robinson and Libs of TikTok, 4
August 2024, 3:07 pm, 10 million views
•
Charlie Kirk on Springfield,
Ohio with Elon Musk’s reply about pet cats, both 9 September 2024, 4.1 million
and 1.7 million views
•
Elon Musk posting video of his
Butler, Pennsylvania appearance of 5 October 2024 captioned “I’m dark MAGA”,
posted 6 October 2024, 3.9 million views
•
Elon Musk, “Dark MAGA
Assemble!”, 6 November 2024, 92.9 million views
•
Elon Musk on hobbits, Gondor
and Tommy Robinson, 29 October 2025, 8:17 am, 1.3 million views. Reported in
Newsweek, Musk
declaring British people ‘hobbits’ sparks backlash, and in The Spectator, No,
Elon Musk: we Brits aren’t hobbits, which identifies the killing of Wayne
Broadhurst in Uxbridge as the trigger
•
Elon Musk, “Save them!”, with
an AI-generated duckling and kitten, 10 September 2024, 7:06 am, 96.1 million
views
•
Elon Musk, “Save them”, with an
AI-generated kitten and puppy, quoting a New York Post report of 14 September
2024 on animal remains in Jamaica Bay, New York, posted 15 September 2024, 46.5
million views
Scholarship
•
Coeckelbergh, M. (2026).
Technofascism: AI, Big Tech, and the new authoritarianism. AI & Society.
https://doi.org/10.1007/s00146-026-02862-9
•
Varoufakis, Y. (2023). Technofeudalism:
What Killed Capitalism. London: Vintage, and Zuboff, S. (2019). The Age
of Surveillance Capitalism. Both are cited here as they appear in
Coeckelbergh’s reference list rather than from the editions themselves.
