Skip to main content

The Cost of SDG Impact: Are Institutions Ready to Pay?

 

The Cost of SDG Impact: Are Institutions Ready to Pay?

Nov 17, 2026

The Cost of SDG Impact: Are Institutions Ready to Pay? A collage of CARE community work across Aotearoa, Singapore, India and the United States

Every university now reports its Sustainable Development Goal impact. The QS Sustainability Rankings score it, the Times Higher Education Impact Rankings score it, and every strategic plan promises it. Reduced inequality. Good health and wellbeing. Peace, justice and strong institutions. Nobody argues with the words, and the words have become a competitive field, with positions won and lost on a point and a half of a composite score.

What almost nobody says out loud is what producing that impact costs and who pays for it. Research that reduces inequality is research that names the arrangements producing inequality. Research that builds peace names the people making war. Research on the health of the poor names the wage, the landlord, the visa and the insurer. The naming is the mechanism. It is what moves the indicator, and it is also what brings the complaint to the Vice-Chancellor's office, the letter from a lawyer, the thread about your competence, the email that mentions your street. Social science that produces real social impact produces real enemies, and what those enemies send is never a rebuttal in a journal. They write to your employer and ask whether you are worth the trouble.

Which leaves a question sitting underneath every sustainability ranking that no methodology asks. Is the institution ready to pay for the impact it says it wants? The dollars are the easy part. The payment is made in reputation, in donor calls returned awkwardly, in ministers displeased, in board members who would rather this went away, in the daily administrative weight of a complaints campaign that somebody has to process. A university that will not carry that weight can still write SDG 10 into its plan. It will simply never produce anything that moves it.

What follows walks through the social impact of CARE, the Center for Culture-Centered Approach to Research and Evaluation, together with my own publication record, the work of our research team and the work of the community partners who built all of it with us. I use us as the worked example because I have the record in front of me, I know what each line of it cost, and I can say who paid. The argument is general. The evidence is ours.

What the SDG record actually holds

A SciVal export of my own Scopus-indexed record, run this month, lists 44 publications from 2022 to 2026 carrying 63 Sustainable Development Goal tags between them. Nearly all of it was produced with CARE researchers and with community partners who co-authored, co-designed or signed off on it. The distribution is worth looking at before anyone draws conclusions from it.

Scopus via SciVal, exported 17 November 2026 · 44 publications, 63 goal tags, 2022 to 2026

Scopus via SciVal, exported 17 November 2026 · 44 publications, 63 goal tags, 2022 to 2026

SDG 10 Reduced Inequalities takes 24 of the 44 publications and 143 of the 185 citations. Add SDG 3 Good Health and Well-being, which overlaps it on four papers, and the pair covers 31 publications and 155 citations. Eight publications sit under SDG 16 Peace, Justice and Strong Institutions, and six of those eight appeared in the last two years, so the citation column there records their age and nothing else. SDG 4 Quality Education returns nothing.

What the chart draws is a map of where our organizing went. Food insecurity in Singapore and Aotearoa. Migrant construction workers. Rohingya refugees living on rations. Māori health and cancer care. Family and sexual violence in the raced, disabled and rainbow margins. Platform workers. Community health workers in India. Every one of those bars is a set of rooms, and in each of those rooms people who are usually written about were instead the ones setting the agenda, choosing the questions, reading the drafts and deciding what left the room.

What sits under a tag

The culture-centered approach starts from a claim about who gets to speak. The communities who carry the heaviest burden of disease, hunger, precarity and violence are the communities least present in the spaces where policy about disease, hunger, precarity and violence is written. That absence is produced. It is held in place by who gets funded, who gets cited, who gets invited, whose language the form is printed in, which meeting happens at which hour, and whose account of a problem counts as evidence. Culture, structure and agency work on each other continuously, and the method is built to open the structure to the voices it was designed to keep out.

In practice that means an advisory group of community members who set the agenda before a single interview is recorded. It means returning to the same neighbourhood for years rather than months, because the first conversation gets you the official version and the fourteenth gets you the truth. It means transcripts going back to the people who spoke them, drafts read by people who have good reason to be careful about what is written down about them, and the authority to say no sitting with the community rather than with the researcher. Deep listening is slow and expensive and it does not fit a three-year funding cycle, which is one of the reasons so little of it gets done.

Two women standing at a wall of chart paper headed Issues and Voting, written in English and Chinese, with sticky notes cast as votes against each issue

Community members voting on the issues that will set the research agenda. The questions belong to the room before a single interview is recorded.

What comes out of those rooms is rarely only a paper. Foreign domestic workers in Singapore built and ran a campaign called Respect our Rights, and the evaluation of it was published nine years after the organizing began. Rohingya refugees in Cox's Bazar documented what living on rations does to a body and a household. Māori whānau theorised health and wellbeing through whakapapa rather than through the deficit frames that the health system kept handing them. Community health workers in India described the stigma and abuse they absorbed while being called heroes. In each case the publication is the residue of an organizing process, and the organizing was the point.

A kitchen table laid out with a month of food aid: canned vegetables, ramen, pasta, bread, eggs, one roll of toilet paper, with a handwritten card reading once every 30 days

A month's food parcel, photographed by the person who received it. Photovoice puts the camera in the hands of the people the policy is written about, and the handwritten card does more than a prevalence table.

The difference between structural work and descriptive work shows up here. A study that documents hunger and stops there has told the funder something the funder already suspected. A study that builds a platform through which hungry people speak into the policy process, and keeps that platform running after the grant ends, has changed a small piece of the architecture. The second kind is harder, slower, and considerably more dangerous.

Naming what produces the inequality

A migrant worker in a Singapore dormitory sleeps twelve to a room because a wage was set low enough to make the dormitory profitable, because his visa is tied to the employer who houses him, because the cost of his recruitment was loaded onto him as debt before he landed, and because a construction sector organised this way delivers buildings at a price the city has decided it likes. Nothing in that sentence is an accident of culture or a shortfall in health literacy. Each clause names a decision, and each decision has a beneficiary.

SDG 10 asks for reduced inequality. Inequality does not arrive like weather. It is manufactured, maintained and defended, and the work of reducing it begins with saying out loud what manufactures it. Patriarchy, which decides whose labour is unpaid and whose body is disposable. Capitalism, which converts a human need into a margin and then calls the result efficiency. Whiteness, which installs itself as the neutral standard against which everyone else is measured and found wanting. White supremacy, which defends that arrangement with violence when the softer methods fail. Colonialism, which took the land and then wrote the history curriculum. Heteronormativity, which makes some families legible to the state and leaves others outside the categories that distribute care. Empire, which does all of this across borders and calls it development, security or aid.

These words cost something to use. Say inequity and a funding panel nods. Say white supremacy and the room changes temperature. The temptation inside a university is to reach for the vocabulary that keeps the room comfortable, and the vocabulary that keeps the room comfortable is the vocabulary that leaves the structure standing. A paper about barriers to access invites a communication campaign. A paper about who built the barrier, who profits from it and who defends it invites a fight. Only one of those papers changes anything, and it is the one that arrives with a complaint attached.

Naming is also what communities ask for. People living inside these arrangements are not confused about what is happening to them. They have an exact account of who is doing it. The erasure happens at the point where their account is translated into the sanitised language a policy document will accept, and the translation is usually performed by a researcher trying to stay employable. Refusing that translation is the most basic obligation the method carries.

A large group of villagers standing and sitting under trees in the rain, some sheltering under black umbrellas, listening to a man speaking

A village meeting held in the rain. The advisory group meets where people are, at the hour that suits them, for as long as the work takes.

Seven men standing outside a tiled-roof house, holding open a handwritten petition addressed to the block development officer

The petition those meetings produced, written in the community's own words and carried to the block development office. The publication is the residue. This is the work.

Peace, justice and the question of who is making the war

SDG 16 reads well in a strategic plan. Peace, justice and strong institutions is the kind of phrase that can be printed on a wall without anyone objecting. The eight publications sitting under it in the chart above come from a programme on preventing family and sexual violence, built with communities at the raced margins, the disability margins, the rainbow margins and among older adults, and that work asks a harder question than the phrase does. Peace for whom, enforced by whom, and at whose expense.

A goal that asks for peace has to account for the organisations manufacturing the opposite. In Aotearoa that means the far right networks that have moved from the fringe into mainstream media coverage and party politics over the last decade, the free speech organisations that host them and then launder the hosting as principle, and the money that pays for both. It means white supremacy operating through respectable channels, as submissions, as think tank reports, as talkback, as a campaign against a curriculum. Globally it means Zionism as a settler colonial political project, which has spent two years underwriting the destruction of Palestinian life while treating any account of that destruction as a disciplinary matter. It means Hindutva, which runs a transnational apparatus capable of mobilising dozens of organisations against a single academic on the other side of the world. It means imperial violence, which arranges the weapons, the trade agreements and the silences that let the first three operate.

Naming those forces is doing SDG 16 work. It is also the fastest way to acquire enemies with resources. The response is never a counterargument in a journal. It is a letter to your employer, a complaint to your regulator, a thread about your competence, a call to a donor, an approach to a board member, a message to a journalist, a question asked in a select committee. The campaign runs through the institution rather than through the field, because the institution is the softer target and because everyone involved understands that an academic without a job publishes nothing. Which puts the whole weight of that goal on its third term. Whether anybody can pursue peace or justice for long enough to produce something depends on whether the institution behind them holds its nerve when the letters start arriving.

The body on the line

In October 2021 a letter reached Massey University carrying the names of fifty six organisations. It asked the university to act against me. The work at issue had named Hindutva as a political project, traced its transnational organising, and documented how it operates in Aotearoa New Zealand. Within weeks there was a webinar explaining to a community audience why I was a danger to them, a petition with a target number, a circulation email telling people which address to write to and what to say, and a file of formal complaints, each of which had to be received, logged, assessed and answered by somebody in a university office. Alongside all of that came the messages to my own inbox, the ones that mention a family, the ones that mention a street.

Three years later the work that campaign set out to stop was in print, and it now sits among the highest impact scholarship CARE has produced. Between the letter and the publication there were advisory group meetings, interviews in people's homes, transcripts, coding, drafts read and re-read by community members who had every reason to be careful about what went into them, and a great many hours that leave no mark on any record. That is what sits underneath a single citation.

While it is happening none of it is abstract. It is sleep. It is a partner checking the locks. It is deciding whether to take the children to the event. It is the hour before a public lecture spent working out where the exits are. It is answering a formal complaint in writing, in your own time, about a claim you have already published the evidence for. The culture-centered approach has held from the beginning that the body is where structure is felt and where it is contested, and that applies to the researcher's body as much as to anybody else's. Standing in the dormitory, on the paepae, at the picket line, in the select committee room, in the hearing, is the method working as it is supposed to.

An older man and a young man standing forehead to forehead with eyes closed in sunlight, the older man's hand at the back of the younger man's neck

Forehead to forehead. The relationship is made before the data and it outlasts the grant, which is why this method cannot be run at arm's length.

Courage here is rarely a solitary performance, which is the part the heroic account of academic freedom usually misses. It is co-authors who put their names on the paper knowing what follows. It is doctoral students who choose the topic anyway. It is a community that keeps turning up to the meeting after a webinar has told them the researcher is dangerous. It is the union that writes the letter. It is the colleague who says the thing in the meeting when looking at the table would have been easier, and the community researcher who signs off on a finding that will make her unpopular in her own networks. Individual nerve runs out quickly on its own. Collective nerve is what sustains a decade of work.

A group of people embracing outdoors under an open sky, arms around one another, others standing close by

Collective nerve. Individual courage runs out quickly on its own, and almost nobody in this photograph is paid to be there.

The organisations that campaign against this scholarship are also its subject matter. The far right network that files the complaint is the network the paper maps. The think tank that writes to the Vice-Chancellor is the think tank whose funding chain the white paper traces. The lobby that demands a correction is the lobby whose reach into the university the research documents. Defending the academy against them is therefore a part of the same justice work rather than a separate administrative chore, because the academy is one of the structures currently under attack by exactly the forces the scholarship names. Agitating against those forces, in public and under your own name, is where the impact in the chart above was actually made.

Paying the bill: the university as a strong institution

Arriving at a university, a campaign of that kind is an invoice. Somebody senior has to decide whether to pay it, and the decision is made early, quickly, by a small number of people, with no public record and usually no policy to hand. Everything that follows over the next decade, the research programme, the community platform, the doctoral students, the publications, the indicator movement a ranking will eventually report, turns on what those few people decide in those first weeks.

Massey supported the work. The Provost, the Pro Vice-Chancellor and the Vice-Chancellor of the time did not ask for the research to be paused while the complaints were reviewed. They did not suggest softer framing. They did not quietly reduce the teaching, the supervision or the platform. They treated academic freedom as the statutory obligation it is under the Education and Training Act, where the university is required to accept the role of critic and conscience of society, and they absorbed the pressure rather than passing it down to me. That is the whole intervention. It sounds like very little and it is the difference between a research programme and a settlement agreement.

Consider what a weaker institution does with the same letter. It commissions an external review to demonstrate that it takes concerns seriously, and the review takes a year. It offers a wellbeing conversation that turns, somewhere in the second half, into a conversation about whether this line of work is sustainable. It asks for a communications plan. It declines to renew a centre's funding on operational grounds. Nobody ever says the word censorship. The research simply becomes impossible to continue, and three years later there is no article, no citation, no community platform and no indicator movement, and the university's sustainability report records a gap it cannot explain.

Universities tell themselves this part of the social impact story least often. The Equality indicator that moved Massey up fifty seven places this year is fed by research outputs on reducing inequality. Research on reducing inequality is produced by people who name the arrangements that produce inequality. Those people get attacked. Whether their work ever reaches publication depends on a handful of senior decisions taken under pressure, years earlier, with nothing in writing. An institution that wants the impact has to be willing to be unpopular on behalf of its staff, and it has to decide that in advance, because the invoice always arrives faster than the policy that was supposed to govern it.

The threat is also internal

Universities tend to picture the threat as external and episodic. A campaign, a letter, a news cycle, something that passes. The external pressure is real and it has become structural. Ministries and policy agencies increasingly carry positions imported from the far right, and they carry them into funding conditions, sector strategies, procurement rules and the terms on which research is commissioned. Priorities are rewritten so that work on structural inequality no longer fits a category. Reviews arrive with their conclusions already drafted. Official information requests are used to generate material for campaigns. None of this requires anybody to ban a topic. It requires only that the money and the categories move.

Councils are the second pressure point, and the one universities understand least well. Appointments to governing bodies are political acts, and a council that includes people whose organisations the research maps will treat that research as a reputational liability rather than as scholarship. The objection is then phrased in the language of risk, brand and stakeholder relationships, and it arrives from inside the governance structure, where it carries far more weight than any letter from outside.

The third pressure is internal, administrative and the most corrosive of the three. Social justice scholarship gets marked as woke, and once the label is attached it becomes available for every ordinary process to act on. A restructure proposal that happens to remove the programmes doing this work. A workload model that reclassifies community organizing as service. A communications policy requiring sign-off before a researcher speaks publicly. An ethics process used as a gate rather than a safeguard. A complaints procedure that lets an external campaign run on institutional rails, each complaint answered on the university's letterhead and in the researcher's unpaid hours. A quiet reclassification of justice scholarship as activism, which is the word institutions reach for when they are preparing to withdraw protection. No one of these is censorship. Together they close a research programme more reliably than censorship would, and they leave no decision anybody can point to.

Committing to SDG impact at institutional level therefore means committing to protect this scholarship in both directions. From the ministry, the agency and the funder outside. From the council, the restructure, the policy and the label inside. A university that defends its staff against an external campaign while running an internal process that does the same work more slowly has made an announcement rather than a commitment.

What the count cannot see

There is a second chart worth putting beside the first, because it says something about the relationship between this kind of work and the instruments now used to measure it.

Scopus via SciVal, exported 17 November 2026 · citations accrued as at 8 November 2026

Scopus via SciVal, exported 17 November 2026 · citations accrued as at 8 November 2026

Eighteen publications from 2025 and 2026, which is forty percent of the whole set, have accrued sixteen citations between them. The violence prevention programme across the raced, disability and rainbow margins, the work with community health workers in India, the campaign evaluation built with foreign domestic workers in Singapore, the reading of health equity under Project 2025, all of it sits in those two near-empty bars. It will register in a ranking round somewhere around 2029. The organizing that produced it began a decade ago.

A ranking year is therefore a report on decisions taken by university leaders six to ten years earlier. The Equality result that Massey is reporting this month was secured by people who protected a research programme in 2021 and 2022, and by communities who kept turning up to meetings long before that. Whatever is decided in a Vice-Chancellor's office this week about which research is too much trouble will show up in the 2033 tables, by which time nobody will connect the two.

The indicators also miss most of the work outright. The chart counts Scopus-indexed outputs, which leaves out books, chapters in volumes the index does not cover, the CARE white paper series, the public writing, the submissions, the community resources, the radio interviews, the evidence given to select committees and the platforms that communities now run themselves. Those are the outputs that move anything. A kuia who can get a complaint heard, a union that wins protective equipment, a group of workers who write their own campaign, none of it has a DOI.

A man in high visibility orange leaning out of a truck window, holding a sign reading hashtag I Choose Highbury

A neighbourhood campaign answering the way the media had written the suburb. No DOI, no field-weighted citation impact, and more effect on the conditions people live under than most of the papers in the chart above.

Children and adults gathered around trestle tables at an outdoor neighbourhood event, with a bouncy castle and a crowd behind them

A community day run by residents. The platform outlasts the grant, which is the part no indicator records and the part communities judge us on.

So the honest version of a sustainability ranking result reads like this. A number went up because a body of work survived. It survived because people in senior offices decided, under pressure, that the research and the researcher were worth defending, because a union and a set of colleagues carried part of the weight, and because communities who had every reason for suspicion decided the research was worth their time anyway. None of those decisions appears anywhere in the methodology. All of them are the method.

Which puts the question back where it belongs. Any university can commit to the Sustainable Development Goals, and nearly all of them have. The work that actually reduces inequality, builds peace and secures health at the margins is adversarial by construction, because the arrangements producing inequality, war and sickness have owners, and the owners defend them. The scholars who take that on will be attacked, and the attack will arrive at the institution rather than in the literature. Everything then turns on whether the institution worked out beforehand what it was prepared to pay. Commit to the goals by all means. Whether the commitment means anything is settled on the week the letters arrive, by whether you stand behind the person who named the structure, before anybody knows how it ends.


Popular posts from this blog

The Haka, the Hurt, and the Work We Owe

  The Haka, the Hurt, and the Work We Owe An Indian in Aotearoa reflects on resistance, complicity, and the solidarities we have yet to build Mohan Jyoti Dutta I watched the haka. I watched it several times, in fact. Each time, I tried to sit with what I was feeling before reaching for what I was supposed to think. Let me be honest about who I am in this conversation, because that matters. I am an upper caste, upwardly mobile Indian man. I am a professor at a university in Aotearoa. I carry the accumulated privileges of Brahminical socialisation, of English-medium education, of institutional access that was never designed for the communities I now write about and alongside. I say this not as confession but as orientation — because where you stand shapes what you see, and I have learned, through years of working with communities at the margins, that the refusal to name your own location is itself a colonial habit. The haka directed at Parmjeet Parmar did not offend me. It ...

The Suit Walks the Corridor

  The Suit Walks the Corridor At ten past nine on a Monday the corridor on the top floor of the administration building fills with the sound of expensive shoes. The carpet up here was laid in the last refurbishment and still gives slightly underfoot, the way a good hotel lobby does, and the doors along it close with the soft, well-engineered thud of a German car. Along this carpet, in the direction of the lift marked Executive, comes the suit. It comes in navy and in charcoal, in the odd daring pinstripe, in the female version too, a tailored jacket over a silk shell, and heels that announce themselves on the tile of the lift lobby a full three seconds before the person arrives. The suit carries a flat white from the good cafe, the one that closed the student cafe to open, and a lanyard that swings with the confidence of a thing that opens doors. The suit passes the framed founding professors, who were photographed in gowns and look, at this distance, like a row of disapproving pe...

The Substack and the Slur: How a Manufactured Crisis Toppled a Wahine Māori Political Editor

  The Substack and the Slur: How a Manufactured Crisis Toppled a Wahine Māori Political Editor On the architecture of the Aotearoa culture-war machine, and the danger it poses to a democracy heading into 2026 There is a particular cadence to the afternoon on which the career of a senior Māori journalist  at TVNZ is finished. It is unhurried. It begins with a tweet — in this case, a single image of a typed statement, posted by Maiki Sherman, the now-former political editor of TVNZ, on the afternoon of Friday, 8 May 2026, announcing that she had parted ways with the broadcaster. The post was terse, dignified, and final. As RNZ later reported , Sherman wrote that the scrutiny of the previous week had placed enormous pressure on her and rendered her role "untenable." The first wahine Māori to lead a major broadcaster's political team was gone. The story that finished her had not, ten days earlier, existed in any newspaper, on any wire, on any website you would consider mai...