Jai Shree Ram in Auckland: Two mainstream NZ parties, the Kia Ora Modi Event and Mainstreamed Hindutva
Jai Shree Ram in Auckland: Two mainstream NZ parties, the Kia Ora Modi Event and Mainstreamed Hindutva
Mohan
J. Dutta
On a winter evening in Auckland this week, under a palm tree on a street
outside the arena where the Prime Minister of India was being celebrated, a
group of men raised a saffron flag bearing the bow and arrow of Ram and the
words Jai Shree Ram. They chanted as they waved it, one of them wearing the
Indian tricolour like a shawl, and by morning the photograph had travelled
proudly through the digital veins of the diaspora. It deserves a longer look
than it got, because if a liberal democracy wants a single test for the arrival
of Hindutva in its public square, that slogan is the test.
Figure 1. Demonstrators outside the Kia
Ora Modi event, Auckland, July 2026, with a saffron Jai Shree Ram flag.
Jai Shree Ram was once a greeting exchanged between pilgrims, and it has
been remade into a war cry: the chant that rolled through the streets of
Leicester in 2022 as communal violence flared half a world from the quarrels
that ignited it, the chant that travels with mobs linked to the RSS and the VHP
when they descend on mosques and minority neighbourhoods in India, a devotion
hollowed out and refilled with menace. When the slogan flies over an Auckland
street it does not fly alone; it arrives in the company of markers the world
has learned to recognise, politicians at Hindutva events, saffron scarves on
parliamentary shoulders, the image of Bharat Mata borne aloft, and the Kia Ora
Modi event gathered a remarkable number of them into a single evening.
The production
Look at the welcome poster the Hindu Council of New Zealand, one of the
nodal organisations of Hindutva, sent into the world: a wharenui in one corner,
the silver fern, the Southern Alps, the two flags braided together, and over it
all the face of Narendra Modi rising like a sun. This is the movement's
signature move, the iconography of the host country draped across the
iconography of the project, the local greeting stretched over the same
travelling production that filled a Houston stadium in 2019 under the name
Howdy, Modi.
Figure 2. Hindu Council of New Zealand
welcome poster for the July 2026 visit.
If the poster supplies the imagery, the Council's Facebook post supplies
the theology, extending a sacred Poornakumbh Swaagatam to the Prime Minister of
Bharat and hymning the timeless bonds of dharma joining Bharat and Aotearoa, so
that a state visit becomes a homecoming of civilisations, a trade mission
becomes dharma, and the vocabulary of the Hindutva movement settles in plain
sight on a New Zealand feed, tagged to the High Commission and the Consulate.
Figure 3. Hindu Council of New Zealand
Facebook post framing the visit through Bharat and dharma.
When the Council's president boasted that every volunteer at the event
was a woman, he reached for the regime's own phrase, Naari Shakti, woman power,
the slogan of a government that garlands womanhood in the abstract while women
human rights defenders grow old in its jails, a vocabulary that needed no
translation on its journey south.
Figure 4. Post by the Hindu Council of
New Zealand president on the event's volunteers as Naari Shakti.
The politicians
Into this production walked the political leadership of New Zealand.
Prime Minister Christopher Luxon stood on the Spark Arena stage beside Modi,
two men waving into a blaze of phone lights, and posted the footage himself,
National MPs arrayed behind him. Every second of it will now be clipped,
subtitled and pushed through the Hindutva ecosystem as recruitment material,
burnishing the image the movement has spent two decades manufacturing: Modi as
vishwaguru, teacher of the world, the singular leader on whose shoulders
authoritarian populism always rests.
Figure 5. Prime Minister Christopher
Luxon's post from the Spark Arena stage.
This is the same country whose own Security Intelligence Service, in the
years after the Christchurch terror attack taught it what Islamophobic
extremism can do, identified Hindutva as a form of extremism in the Aotearoa
context, and it now has a Prime Minister who says he is not worried about
Hindutva in New Zealand even as he parades into a Hindutva rally and wakes the
next morning on the front pages of the Hindutva-linked media in India.
Labour offered no counterweight: Jenny Salesa filmed the twelve thousand
inside the arena and pronounced the vibe amazing, while Chris Hipkins went to
meet Modi with Vanushi Walters, who wrote warmly of the growing partnership
between our two democracies. The warmth was bipartisan and so was the silence.
Figure 6. Labour MP Jenny Salesa's post
from inside Spark Arena.
Figure 7. Labour MP Vanushi Walters' post
on meeting Modi with Labour leader Chris Hipkins.
The most telling image from Auckland, though, is the one that was never
taken, because Modi does not hold press conferences: across more than a decade
in office he has not taken unscripted questions from his own country's
journalists, years in which the Varieties of Democracy Institute downgraded the
world's largest democracy to an electoral autocracy, its newsrooms raided, its
scholars jailed, its universities hollowed out. Of the two democracies toasted
at Spark Arena, only one still answers to its people, and neither of New
Zealand's major parties found a word to say about it.
The cost
None of this is new to these islands. Narendra Modi first came to New
Zealand in 2001, as a functionary of the Bharatiya Janata Party and a senior
member of the RSS, before his years as Chief Minister of Gujarat, and the
mainstream arrival of Hindutva here has been building ever since, in full view
of a documentary base assembled with patience and at personal cost: the white
papers published by the Center for Culture-Centered Approach to Research and
Evaluation, the encyclopedia entries recording the movement's presence in
Aotearoa, the organising of activists such as Sapna Samant and Oscar Romero,
the sustained work of the Aotearoa Alliance of Progressive Indians, and five
years of excellent reporting that traced the evidence and the linkages. The
scenes captured in these photographs unfolded with that record open on the
table, which makes them a choice rather than an oversight, and the bill for the
choice will be presented twice.
It will be presented first in New Zealand, where the arrival of one
majoritarian fury summons another: Hindutva hands Destiny Church and Brian
Tamaki the enemy their Christian nationalism requires, and receives from them
the enemy it requires in return, while Muslims, Sikhs, Dalits, tangata whenua
and queer communities are caught in the space between them.
The thousands who streamed into Spark Arena came, most of them, for
reasons as old as migration itself: to hear the songs of home in a southern
winter, to see the leader of the country they left honoured by the country they
chose, to stand for one evening inside a crowd that pronounced their names
correctly. There is nothing to apologise for in that longing. But it is
precisely this longing that the production harvests: the warmer the welcome and
the fuller the arena, the louder the declaration to those trained to hear it.
And it will be presented in India, where every arena filled in a western
democracy returns as proof that the world has blessed the project, that the
raids and the jailings carry no cost abroad. The applause in Auckland does not
stay in Auckland.
A saffron flag with a war cry flew over an Auckland street this week, and
the political leadership of this country stood inside the arena it pointed
toward. New Zealand should say plainly what it saw.