The Same Men Are Building the Machines
The Same Men Are Building the Machines
Mohan Dutta
This essay is opinion. The views in it
are my own. Every statement I attribute to a person is quoted or summarised
from a public post, a public record or published reporting, and the sources are
linked throughout and listed at the end. Where I say what I think somebody's
words mean, the judgement is mine and readers are free to reach a different one
from the same material.
In July 2025 a stadium camera at a Coldplay
concert outside Boston found Andy Byron, the chief executive of the data
company Astronomer, with his arms around Kristin Cabot, the company's chief
people officer. Chris Martin guessed from the stage that either they were
having an affair or they were very shy. Within three days Byron had resigned
and the board had accepted it, saying its leaders were expected to set the
standard in conduct and accountability, and that the standard had not been met.
Cabot resigned the following week.
In Aotearoa, the commentator Ani O'Brien
posted that Byron should not have needed to go, and that if people were
pressured to resign over affairs there would be a lot of unemployed people. I
replied that the post showed no grasp of organisational ethics or
organisational culture, and that the amoral capitalist world it imagined was
the stuff of dystopian nightmares.
John-Daniel Trask then came into the
thread. He co-founded and runs Raygun, the Wellington software diagnostics
company used by teams in more than a hundred countries, and he co-founded and
runs Autohive, which sells itself as a platform for turning every organisation
into an AI organisation. He posted that I was a man who pretends he never ever
does anything wrong, angry that cancel culture might be going away. When I said
he did not understand the basics of HR policy in 2025, he told me he had built
several businesses over twenty years, that this included HR and hundreds of
staff, that his bio did not list an employer like mine, and that I had zero
clue what I was talking about. Boyd Broughton asked him whether an employer
could really be unaware of the power dynamics of a chief executive sleeping
with his staff. I said that here was a chief executive defending the behaviour,
that his companies build AI products, and that I shuddered to think what
ethical guidelines those products follow. He answered that he had not defended
the behaviour, that he had attacked my cancel culture bullshit, and that I
should learn to read.
So I asked him what was cancel culture
about holding chief executives accountable, and whether he was suggesting that
chief executives sit beyond accountability. In the thread as I kept it, that
question has no reply under it. I take that silence as the answer. A man who
sells software for running organisations, who had just told me he understood HR
because he had employed hundreds of people, produced no sentence explaining why
a chief executive who slept with the head of his own HR function should keep
his job, and no sentence conceding that he should not. What he did produce was
the swearing, the credential, and the instruction to learn to read.


Wry and puckish
Fifteen months later, four days out from
the 2026 general election, Michael
Laws sat behind a microphone at The Platform and worked his way through the
appearance of a woman standing against him. Kayla Kingdon-Bebb was the
Opportunity Party candidate for Wellington Bays. Laws told his listeners it
must be hell dating people like that, described her as severe and disapproving,
said she reminded him of an officious primary school teacher, noted that her
dress came down to her calves and that she wore little makeup, and then asked
his audience to imagine what her face looked like after sex. He added that he
had said it out loud, and that yes, he had meant to.
When the New Zealand Herald published the
remarks, Laws went back on air and said they were not sexist. He said that
calling someone an infant schoolmistress in all aspects of their life was not
sexist. He said he had been puckish his entire life and did not intend to stop
being mischievous and teasing on that radio show. End of story, he said. He
called the reaction professional offence and noted that when he is on The
Platform he is not a candidate, he is a broadcaster. Hours later, after Winston
Peters called the language unacceptable and promised to tell him so, Laws
produced the apology that the form requires and the content empties. It was not
his intent to cause offence, he said, but to be wry and puckish in his
observation, and so if people were offended, he apologised. He accepted the
reprimand. He would not say whether he thought the comments were sexist or
misogynistic.
Qiulae Wong, who leads the Opportunity
Party and who Laws had also gone after, said he was feeding a toxic culture and
asked whether the country really needed him back in Parliament. Nicola
Willis called the comments disgusting, Chlöe Swarbrick called them gross, David
Seymour called them gross and stupid. The condemnation ran the full width
of the House, which tells you how safe it was to issue. Four months earlier,
when Stuart Nash called a National MP one of the laziest after she took
parental leave, NZ
First accepted his resignation as its Napier candidate within hours. Laws,
at number six on the list, was not asked for his. Peters said he could not
properly deal with it before the election. On 7 November the voters returned
the list, and Laws says
he is not going to quit. He is an incoming member of Parliament and still
an Otago regional councillor, and he has told that council that what he says on
the radio has nothing to do with his work there.
The record behind this is thirty years long
and the pattern inside it never changes. In 2006 he called the late
Tongan king a bloated, brown slug on air and the Broadcasting Standards
Authority cleared him. In 2010 he called the Governor-General a fat Indian,
refused to apologise, and only apologised when another broadcaster lost a job
for something similar. The complaints accumulate, the rulings mostly fall his
way, the employers keep the slot open, and the man carries on. What I take Laws
to have learned across three decades is that the words cost him nothing, which
is why he can say on air that he does not intend to stop. On my reading he is
reporting a finding.
Women driven by emotion
Two days after the election, Newsroom
published an account of an afternoon spent poolside at the Zuru mansion in
Coatesville, the Auckland property where the money behind the Split Your Vote
campaign had gathered. Harry Mowbray, father of the Zuru billionaires and the
architect and funder of that campaign, explained to a reporter why he wants the
electoral system changed. Parliament is elected by the swing voter, he said,
and that
swing voter happens to be female because they vote emotionally. He named
them: the Remuera lady, the Hamilton solo mum. The whole of the party vote
system, he said, is women driven by emotion, and that is what the left always
argues about. His analysis of MMP is that the country will always move left,
because the women at the centre of it can be reached with the promise of a few
more dollars.
The country he describes gave women the
vote in 1893 and he has worked out that this was the design flaw. A man with
enough money to fund a vote-splitting campaign that helped produce a record
overhang looked at the electorate, found women in the middle of it, and said in
plain words that they vote emotionally. I read that as a judgement that their
judgement is a defect in the machinery, and the campaign as an attempt to
reduce its effect. He said this to a journalist, on the record, at his own
house, beside his own pool, because nothing in his experience of the world
suggested there would be a cost. Michele
A'Court and Deborah
Coddington and others wrote the columns, the Spinoff ran the
headline about the angry man swearing about politics, and the campaign he
funded has already done its work on the shape of the Parliament now being
negotiated. Columns are not a cost.
Put Laws and Mowbray beside each other and
the machinery shows. One is a broadcaster speaking to a provincial audience
about a woman's hemline and her face after sex. The other is a very rich man
speaking to a national outlet about women as the emotional weakness in a voting
system. The register is different and the finding is the same: women appear in
the account as objects to be assessed, and the man doing the assessing is
confident that assessing them in public is his to do. Neither man is a fringe figure.
One is entering Parliament on a party list and the other has spent his money
shaping which Parliament that is.
The man who would be honoured to return
While New Zealand was counting its special
votes, the most powerful chief executive in the AI industry was losing his job
for exactly the conduct that John-Daniel Trask had refused to call a firing
offence. On 29 October 2026 the New York Times reported that
Jensen Huang had been the target of a plot involving the Chinese government,
centred on his relationship with Alice Huang, no relation, an executive of a
firm whose purchases of Nvidia chips were already under investigation by the
United States Commerce Department. Huang told Bloomberg that Nvidia's dealings
with the firm had been completely normal. On 5 November Nvidia's general
counsel went to his house and asked him whether the reports of an affair were
true, and he said they were. On 8 November he apologised to his staff for
marital infidelity. He told senior executives that this was his only such
relationship, which The
Information later reported was untrue. On 11 November the New York Times
reported a second relationship, with Kimberly Powell, a vice president whose
supervisor he was. The board met that evening and accepted his resignation as
chief executive, president and director, effective immediately. By then roughly
1.5 trillion dollars had come off the company's market value since early
October and shareholders had filed a class action. The allegation that Alice
Huang worked for Chinese intelligence is contested: the Attorney General said
on 12 November that the Justice Department had reached no conclusion on it, and
China's foreign ministry called the claim a fabrication. Nothing in my argument
turns on that question. What is not in dispute is the relationship with a
subordinate, Huang's own apology for infidelity, and the board's decision.
What happened next is the part worth
holding onto. Within four days the Financial Times reported that Huang was
weighing a comeback and that his allies had set up a lobbying war room,
including approaches to the White House. Nvidia employees petitioned for his
return. On 17 November, with the company having said it had no plan to
reinstate him, Huang put out a statement saying he saw an outpouring of calls
for him to come back and would
be honoured to return. A man reported to have given his own executives an
incomplete account, whose conduct had put a counterintelligence question over
the company that supplies the world's AI compute, and who had been in a
supervisory relationship with a subordinate he was involved with, read nine
days of consequence and concluded, in his own published statement, that the
appropriate next step was restoration.
Set that against the question Trask would
not answer. The suggestion was never that affairs are the public's business.
The suggestion is that a chief executive who conducts a sexual relationship
with a person whose pay, promotion and employment he controls has used the
power the company gave him, and that an organisation which keeps him has told
every other employee what its grievance process is worth. Nvidia's board
understood this well enough to act, and acted only after a second relationship
surfaced and the share price had moved. The lesson I draw from what is
happening in public right now is that even at that scale, with national
security counsel retained and a congressional subpoena threatened, the man
expects to come back, and a meaningful part of his industry expects it with
him.
Sixteen months later
Over sixteen days in November 2026, while
the Huang story ran, John-Daniel Trask posted three times on X. I read those
three posts as the answer he declined to give me in July 2025, and I set them
out here so that readers can judge them for themselves.
On 5 November, after the United States
midterms, Congresswoman Yassamin Ansari of Arizona posted that the top of the
Democratic agenda on day one needed to be a pause on advanced AI development, regulation
of what she called this out of control industry, and a ban on artificial
superintelligence. Trask quoted her and wrote that America had decided to
commit suicide. On 12 November, as Nvidia announced Huang's resignation, the
markets account Geiger Capital posted the New York Times report that Huang had
been in a relationship with an Nvidia executive who reported to him. Trask
quoted it and wrote that the trick is to marry the VP in your company. On 20
November, after it was reported that Nvidia's
interim chief executive Colette Kress had opened the company's first all-hands
meeting since the resignation by telling staff to move forward, with
employees pushing for Huang's return, Trask quoted that story and wrote that it
gave off evil stepmom vibes.
My reading of the three is this. The first
holds that regulating his own industry would be an act of national
self-destruction, which is to say that the people who build these systems
should answer to nobody holding a statute. The second takes the precise conduct
we had argued about in 2025, a chief executive in a sexual relationship with a
woman whose pay and promotion he controls, and renders it a question of
paperwork with a workaround available to any man willing to marry her. The
third is aimed at the woman left holding the consequences, a chief financial
officer handed an interim title and the job of telling staff to stop
campaigning for the man whose conduct emptied the chair, and it reaches for a
fairytale villain from the standard stock of things said about women who end up
in charge.
They read as jokes, and I expect they were
meant as jokes. Jokes are where a person keeps what they have stopped bothering
to argue for. In my view the sequence shows that nothing shifted in sixteen
months: the question of whether chief executives answer to anyone had an answer
the whole time, and it came in three lines while the biggest accountability
story in the history of the industry was still running.



What a shrug builds
An AI system is a set of judgements about
people made at scale and at speed by a process nobody in the room can fully
inspect. Someone decides which training data counts and which is noise. Someone
decides what a good outcome looks like, which complaints get routed to a human,
which get closed, what a fair ranking is, whose face the system recognises and
whose it does not. Those decisions are made inside companies by people, and the
decisions carry the dispositions of the people who make them. This is why I
said in that thread that I shuddered to think what ethical guidelines the
products would follow. The question was not rhetorical, and the worry is mine
rather than a finding about any particular product. My view is that a founder
who will not say out loud that a chief executive sleeping with his own HR chief
is a problem has shown something about where his own threshold for an internal
power complaint sits. Products built by companies like his are sold into
schools, clinics, councils and workplaces, and somewhere inside them sits a
decision about whose account is believed.
New Zealand has decided to find out what
happens when such people are left to set their own terms. The AI Strategy
released in July 2025 commits the country to a light-touch and
principles-based approach that creates no new AI law and leans on existing
privacy, consumer and human rights statutes. As at October 2026 there is no
AI-specific statute here. Christopher Luxon has stuck with that setting while
acknowledging serious dangers and evils in the technology, and the
only party to release an AI policy for the 2026 election was the Greens.
New Zealand sits 32nd of 45 high-income countries on the
Global Index on Responsible AI. Light touch is a decision about who holds
the pen, and it hands the pen to the founders.
The case for that arrangement rests on an
assumption about character. It holds that the people building these systems
will be constrained by professional norms, reputational risk and their own
ethical sense, so that law would only slow them down. Every scene in this essay
tests that assumption, and in my reading of them it fails. The broadcaster says
the words cost him nothing and he has three decades of evidence. The funder
says women vote emotionally and the campaign he paid for still shapes the Parliament.
The chief executive of the most important company in the industry breaks the
rule, misleads his executives, loses the job, and starts a lobbying operation
to get it back while staff circulate a petition. The local founder, asked a
direct question about whether chief executives are accountable to anyone,
swears, invokes his payroll, and tells the person asking to learn to read.
On the record set out above, none of these
men was stopped by character. Three of them were barely stopped at all. The one
who was stopped is still asking to come back.
Accountability is a structure, not a feeling
The word accountability gets used in this
debate as though it described a mood. It describes a set of arrangements, and
the arrangements are ordinary. A duty written into statute that attaches to a
named person inside the company. A requirement to disclose what a system was
trained on, what it was tested for, and who it failed during testing. An
obligation to keep records that a regulator can demand. Standing for the person
harmed, so that the woman whose application was ranked down, the beneficiary
whose file was flagged, the tenant screened out by a model can bring a claim
without having to prove the intentions of an engineer she will never meet. A
regulator with the money and the staff to look. Penalties large enough that the
finance director notices. In Aotearoa this work sits under te Tiriti o
Waitangi, which means data sovereignty and Māori governance over systems built
on Māori data, and it means that the Crown's obligations do not evaporate
because a vendor wrote the code.
Every one of those arrangements exists
because somebody once argued that it was unnecessary, that the professionals
concerned were decent people, and that regulation would smother a promising
industry. Mine safety law, food law, the Employment Relations Act, the Privacy
Act: each arrived after the argument from character had been tested against
bodies and files. We know what the argument from character is worth in this
industry now, because the test was run in public over nine days in November and
the subject of the test is currently lobbying to be given his company back.
What I see in these men is the ordinary
culture of the executive suite rather than a departure from it, along with a
fluency in the vocabulary that protects them. Cancel culture is the name given
to the experience of being asked a question. Wry and puckish is the name given
to a sexual remark about a woman on the ballot. Professional offence is the
name given to the people who object. Each phrase does the same work, which is
to move the problem from the man's conduct to the character of whoever named it.
When the industry that is automating decisions about work, welfare, policing
and health is run by people fluent in that vocabulary, writing law is not an
attack on innovation. It is the only mechanism anybody has ever found for
making a powerful man answer a question he does not want to answer.
I asked one such question in July 2025. The
answer was that I should learn to read. The answer the public is entitled to,
and the answer that only legislation can compel, is the one that begins: here
is what the system does, here is who is responsible when it does it wrongly,
and here is what happens to them.
Sources
|
Item |
Source |
|
Astronomer resignation, board statement
on conduct and accountability |
|
|
Kristin Cabot resignation |
|
|
John-Daniel Trask, roles at Raygun and
Autohive |
|
|
Laws remarks, on-air defence and apology;
Wong and Peters responses |
|
|
Cross-party condemnation of Laws |
|
|
Laws refusing to quit; incoming MP |
|
|
Stuart Nash resignation as NZ First
candidate |
|
|
Laws record: 2006 and 2010 remarks, BSA
outcomes, current roles |
|
|
Harry Mowbray, "women driven by
emotion", Split Your Vote |
|
|
Commentary on Mowbray |
Michele
A'Court, Stuff; Deborah
Coddington, NZ Herald; The
Spinoff, 13 November 2026 |
|
Huang scandal timeline, resignation,
investigations |
Wikipedia,
Jensen Huang scandal; TechCrunch,
19 November 2026 |
|
Huang "honored" to return |
|
|
NZ AI Strategy, light-touch approach, no
AI statute |
|
|
Party AI policy at the 2026 election |
|
|
NZ ranking on the Global Index on
Responsible AI |
Ansari's call for a pause, regulation and a
superintelligence ban: The
State of AI; Fortune,
17 November 2026. Colette Kress at the all-hands meeting of 18 November
2026: Techstrong
AI.
The posts by John-Daniel Trask are
reproduced from screenshots of his public account on X, dated 21 July 2025 and
5, 12 and 20 November 2026, and the screenshots appear above so that readers
can see the posts in full and form their own view of them. He has not been
asked for comment on this essay, and I will publish any response he wishes to
make.
